Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

232 Tally Ho Road
Courtesy of RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group, Patricia M Sassi Listing Contact: 845-341-0004 
Sold

232 Tally Ho Road

232 Tally Ho Road, Middletown, NY 10940

$800,000
A Rare Country Estate Rich in History, Character & Timeless Beauty. Nestled off the road and surrounded by approximately 17 private, wooded acres, this remarkable circa 1820 estate offers an extraordinary opportunity to own a piece of Hudson Valley history. Lovingly expanded over generations while preserving its original character, this one of a kind residence encompasses over 4,500 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space where historic craftsmanship and modern comfort exist in perfect harmony. From the moment you arrive, the setting is unforgettable. Mature trees, rolling lawns, handcrafted stone walls, beautifully landscaped gardens, and multiple patios create a peaceful retreat where nature becomes part of everyday life. Inside, authentic architectural details celebrate the home's rich heritage. Original woodwork, custom built-ins, exposed beams, hardwood floors, handcrafted moldings, and three fireplaces create warmth and character throughout. Every room offers a unique glimpse into the home's remarkable history while providing comfortable spaces for today's lifestyle. The stunning great room is truly the heart of the home, showcasing reclaimed hand-hewn beams salvaged from a local barn and an impressive floor to ceiling stone fireplace crafted from stone found right on the property. Nearby, an incredible sunroom with soaring wood ceilings, skylights, walls of glass, and beautiful terracotta style flooring invites you to relax while enjoying panoramic views of the surrounding landscape in every season. A thoughtfully designed private wing introduces a distinctive Southwestern-inspired aesthetic, creating an exceptional primary suite complete with a fireplace, spacious ensuite bath, private balcony, and adjoining first-floor living area. Whether used as a luxurious owner's retreat, guest quarters, or a comfortable multi-generational living space, this flexible wing offers endless possibilities while adding a unique architectural dimension to the home. Outside, the property continues to impress. A classic original barn featuring horse stalls, electric service, and an expansive loft provides incredible versatility for equestrian enthusiasts, hobby farmers, livestock, workshops, storage, or future creative pursuits. With acres of wooded privacy and open areas for horses, chickens, goats, gardening, or simply enjoying the outdoors, the possibilities are limited only by your imagination. As an added opportunity, an adjoining 16.7-acre parcel is also available for purchase, allowing the next owner to create an even more extraordinary private estate. Steeped in nearly two centuries of history yet thoughtfully adapted for modern living, this is more than a home it's a legacy property waiting for its next chapter.

4
beds

5
baths

4,522 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

17 Acres lot

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms4
  • Total bathrooms5
  • full bathrooms4
  • half bathroom1
  • Laundry room In Bathroom
  • Flooring Carpet, Hardwood, Tile
  • Fireplace Gas, Wood Burning
  • APPLIANCES Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
  • other interior Features Eat-in Kitchen, Formal Dining, Natural Woodwork, Original Details, Primary Bathroom, Washer/Dryer Hookup

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Date Sold October 13, 2026
  • Living Area4,522 Sq.Ft.
  • Total Area4,522 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area17 Acres
  • MLS® ID1032582
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1820
  • NeighborhoodMiddletown
  • Architecture StylesColonial, Farmhouse
  • Elementary SchoolMinisink Valley Elementary
  • Middle SchoolMinisink Valley Middle School
  • High SchoolMinisink Valley High School
  • School DistrictMinisink Valley

Exterior

  • STORIES2
  • water SourceWell
  • utilitiesElectricity Connected, Propane, Trash Collection Private
  • lot featuresBack Yard, Front Yard, Landscaped, Level, Part Wooded, Secluded
  • parkingDriveway, Oversized
  • HEAT TYPEOil
  • AIR CONDITIONINGAttic Fan, Wall/Window Unit(s)
  • sewerSeptic Tank
  • SubstructureStone
  • other exterior FeaturesBalcony, Garden, Mailbox

Financial

  • Sales Price$800,000
  • Real Estate Tax $17,414/yr
Patricia Sassi

Patricia Sassi

Paul Ruszkiewicz

Paul Ruszkiewicz

Middletown

Explore

Your Resource, Your Expert,

Your Realtor.

You deserve a team that tells you what to expect and then delivers. We keep our process organized, our communication open, and our advice honest. Whether you are buying your first home or selling a longtime family property, we are here to make the path simpler.

Follow Me on Instagram